The Shelter Island Food Pantry - although a separate entity from the Church - is housed in and offers its services at the Shelter Island Presbyterian Church. With the Pantry open two days a week offering both morning and afternoon/evening hours, the volunteers create opportunity for many Islanders who have food insecurity to come get what they need without questions.
During the summer months, the Food Pantry receives special donations of fresh vegetables from Sylvester Manor. Throughout the year donations made by local individuals, groups and churches fund the purchase of staples and fresh food.